An Open Epistle to Ecumenical Patriarch Bartholomew From Elder Gabriel of Mount Athos – Slobodan Tomic

Регион Свет

An English translation

Your All-Holiness,

During your recent visit to the Holy Mountain of Athos – that earthly domain of the Most Holy Mother of God, our Theotokos – I greatly desired to receive your patriarchal blessing and to kiss your feet. Unfortunately, I was unable to do so, because such an act has long since come to be regarded as something sinful. Would you like to know why?

1.Through your fruitless and deceitful dialogues with heretics, you and your associates have betrayed the One and Only Church – Holy Orthodoxy. On numerous occasions, you have acknowledged so-called “diversity” in the holy dogmas and granted the status of Church to heretical Monophysite para-synagogues, to the Pope of Rome, and to Protestants, who are iconoclasts and enemies of the Most Holy Theotokos.

Furthermore, in the presence of everyone, you uttered blasphemy against the Holy Fathers, calling them “unfortunate victims of the ancient serpent, the progenitor of evil”, and you have not repented of those words. You did so in order not to give others the impression that you were bound to heed their God-pleasing admonitions.

2.You are an enemy of the Triune God and of our Mother of God, because, at the ecclesiastical level, you associate with conscious and unrepentant heretics and people of other faiths, with those who become depraved, sin and condemn themselves (Titus 3:11), with advocates of heresies and defenders of ungodliness.

Together with them, you will embark upon the path to eternal torment, far removed from the land of the living, unless you return to the true faith.

For Saint John Chrysostom says:

“Whoever associates with the enemies of the king cannot be his friend. By the very nature of his conduct, he is unworthy and perishes together with the enemies… deserving even the most terrible punishment.”

He also teaches that “hatred for the sake of Christ is far better than fellowship on account of Him.”

Do you not remember the divinely inspired words of Holy Scripture?

“Both the ungodly and his ungodliness are alike hateful unto God” (Wisdom of Solomon 14:9).

3.Under your patriarchal protection, your patronage and your shelter, every heresy and every newly emerging departure from the faith finds refuge – not only within the dioceses of the See of Constantinople, but also in the Church of Greece and elsewhere.

Your clergy, theologians and scholars, whom you reward with distinguished titles, participate in prestigious conferences and publish their works, celebrating your supposedly “wise patriarchal governance”.

Yet all of them are founders and originators of all manner of previously unseen theological heresies and innovations within the Church, beginning with so-called metapatristic theology and the pagan cult of the Earth, disguised in the garb of environmental activism, and culminating in the “restoration to the priestly rank” of the unrepentant Ukrainian schismatics.

Beside you, all these spiritual wolves find refuge and justification against the thunderous condemnation of the Orthodox clergy. You are their shepherd and protector.

According to the words of the Holy Fathers, you are in complete agreement with them:

“How can those who have failed to raise their voices against impiety, and have not stood in defence of those who oppose it and are consequently persecuted, not be considered equally impious?”

4.As though you were a second Pope, for three decades you have been instilling within the fullness of the Church the notion that every wish of every bishop, and above all that of the Ecumenical Patriarch, constitutes a law for the Church.

How severely the Holy Fathers whom you insult through your statements condemn both you and the Pope!

How fitting for you are the words of Saint Gregory Palamas, addressed to your predecessor on the patriarchal throne, the heretic John XIV Kalekas, who was condemned by a council:

“He considered himself alone to be the council, because he repeatedly called himself ‘the Church’. Whatever he said and whatever he preached concerning the Church, he considered to be the only correct position. He declared that the entire Church thought as he did.”

5.Through your actions and teachings, you demonstrate disregard for the canons of the Holy Apostles, the Holy Local and Ecumenical Councils, and the Holy Tradition of the Fathers.

These strictly prohibit joint prayers, cooperative ecclesiastical relations and common worship with heretics.

Our Church maintains that:

“He who believes that he possesses the correct faith but does not submit to the divine canons is not fully Orthodox, but only partially so.”

Consequently, you demonstrate that you do not believe in God, in the immortality of the soul, in the invisible world, in Paradise, in Hell, in the Last Judgement, or in the hope of salvation.

Your All-Holiness, do you perhaps believe that private meetings with representatives and benefactors of Masonic lodges and other orders associated with them testify to your elevated position and status within the Church?

All of this is incompatible with the Orthodox faith and profoundly contrary to it.

6.Unfortunately, those who ought to receive courteous guidance from you and your associates, but whose conduct is not consistent with the sacred order of the Orthodox Church, know all too well that anyone who opposes your methods of spreading ecumenism is subjected to isolation and alienation from the community in which they live. They are then compelled either to remain silent or to leave.

You also resort to political interference, as you did on the Holy Mountain of Athos.

Therefore, the words of Saint Athanasius the Great, describing the characteristic conduct of the heretics who followed Arius, apply fully to you:

“Truth is not restored by the sword and arrows, nor by the assistance of soldiers, but through persuasion and counsel. What kind of persuasion can there be where fear of the emperor prevails? Or what kind of counsel exists where the one who objects is threatened with imprisonment or death?”

Regardless of the fact that you, Your All-Holiness, have often put on the mask of an Orthodox Christian, your words have contradicted your deeds and, indeed, the very manner in which you think.

Yet, according to Saint Gregory Palamas, even if you had merely wavered in some matter concerning Orthodoxy, you would already have been unworthy of the sacred priestly office:

“The Holy Canons prescribe that those who at one time agree with piety and at another reject it are to be deprived of the priesthood, for the canons disqualify the one who is not steadfast in piety and who again embraces shameless false doctrine.”

Because of you, every Orthodox Greek is confronted with a choice: either to act out of love for Christ, the God-Man, or to submit to a hierarch authorised to be the “Patriarch of the Nation”.

Indeed, approximately 1,600 years ago, Saint Cyril of Alexandria wrote to the heretic Nestorius, then head of the Church of Constantinople and your predecessor:

“What are we to endure, when your Reverence demands from us greater love for you than for Christ, the Saviour of us all? Who will help us on the Day of Judgement? Or what justification shall we find for ourselves when we remain silent for so long in the face of such blasphemy against Christ?”

Your All-Holiness, the injury you inflict upon the Body of Christ – the Church – is, in fact, a rebellion against the Saviour Himself.

Throughout the twenty-eight years of your rule, you have undertaken not a single action that would bring joy and consolation to the hearts of true Orthodox Christians.

You please only those who possess the wisdom of this world.

All the awards and distinctions of honour bestowed upon you by the rulers of this world, which lies in wickedness (1 John 5:19), were not granted in honour of the saving truth of Orthodoxy, but rather to encourage you to belittle it.

And that is precisely what you do, using every means at your disposal.

Your All-Holiness!

Repent, and cease walking along the broad and soul-destroying path upon which you have been relentlessly advancing!

Through your path and the direction in which you are leading the Church, you are inflicting damage upon the pure and uncorrupted Orthodox mind and upon the unity among the Orthodox, affecting millions of baptised souls, for whom you will have to give a terrible, “ecumenical” account before the incorruptible Judgement of God.

You will tremble at the thought that the immaterial and eternal Hell is filled with unrepentant hierarchs and patriarchs.

The history of the Church knows well the instances in which patriarchs and their highest-ranking circles became leaders of heresy and were condemned, beginning with the foremost among them – the fallen apostle and betrayer, Judas Iscariot.

Above all, divine judgement begins with us, the servants of the Church:

“For the time has come for judgement to begin at the house of God; and if it begins with us first, what will be the end of those who do not obey the Gospel of God?” (1 Peter 4:17).

Therefore, Your All-Holiness, walk while it is still day, lest darkness overtake you, when no one can work (John 12:35; John 9:4).

Monk Gabriel of Karyes

Cell of the Venerable Christodoulos of Patmos Koutloumousiou Monastery Holy Mountain of Athos

11 November 2019

Please follow and like us: