Opinion by Slobodan TOMIC – Exporting silence: When science, money, and power touch the dignity of the dead

Македонија Свет

By: Slobodan TOMIC

Slobodan TOMIC

“When a civilization begins to treat death as a resource, it loses the right to call itself human.”

Karl Jaspers

THE HISTORY OF HUMANITY BEGINS WITH RESPECT FOR THE DEAD

No civilization is measured by its skyscrapers, but by the way it bids farewell to its dead.From the Egyptian pyramids, through the ancient Macedonian tombs in Vergina, to the Orthodox rites of the Balkans — respect for the dead has always marked the boundary between civilization and barbarism,а dead human being has never been merely a biological remainder.He was memory. History.Family. Dignity.That is why every attempt to turn the human body into “material,” without absolute transparency and moral certainty, opens questions that are not merely medical — but civilizational.

THE CASE OF BRAIN SAMPLES – BETWEEN SCIENCE AND SUSPICION

The facts are serious and must not be ignored.Between 1994 and 2015, a scientific cooperation existed between Macedonian medical institutions and Columbia University in the United States.During that period, hundreds of brain tissue samples obtained from autopsies were processed.Scientists claim that this was a legal project, based on family consent and approvals from ethics committees.However, questions emerged in the public sphere that cannot be dismissed by administrative formulations.History has taught us that abuses rarely begin with crime, but with insufficient transparency.

THE MINISTRY OF HEALTH AND THE ADMINISTRATIVE WALL

The Ministry clearly stated that it has no direct jurisdiction over scientific research activities.Formally, this is correct.Morally, however, it opens a new dilemma.When human biological material is involved, the state cannot hide behind administrative boundaries.Responsibility becomes collective, institutional, ethical, and societal.Therefore, the working group now being formed must not be a bureaucratic exercise, but a historical test of public trust.

SCIENCE AS A NOBLE MISSION — AND AS A RISK ZONE

There is no doubt that brain research has immense scientific value.Diseases such as schizophrenia, depression, and suicide represent some of the greatest medical challenges of the modern world.Yet history warns that science without ethics can become the most dangerous weapon.From Nazi medical experiments, through the Tuskegee Study in the United States, to contemporary scandals involving organ trafficking — the justification has always begun with “scientific interest.”

THE FINANCIAL SHADOW THAT MUST NEVER BE IGNORED

The industry connected to human tissue is among the most profitable medical sectors in the world.This does not automatically imply criminal activity.But it does mean that risk exists.Especially when a name such as Jeffrey Epstein appears in the narrative — a symbol of a global network of power, money, and abuse.Even if his foundation legally financed scientific projects, the mere presence of such a figure imposes a moral obligation of maximum transparency.

THE QUESTION THAT HURTS EVERY FAMILY: WAS THE CONSENT TRULY INFORMED?

Legal consent and informed consent are not the same.One can be a signature.The other is understanding.Did families truly know that brains were being removed?Were they informed what that meant?Were they told where the samples would end up?Particularly tragic is the question of patients without active families — people forgotten in institutions, who may have become “easy material” for scientific collections.

WHEN MEDICINE FACES ITS HARDEST MORAL DILEMMA: SAVING OR SURRENDERING

In cases of suicide or deep coma, there is always a line between medical reality and human hope.Was everything that medicine allows always done to save life?This question is not an accusation.It is a moral obligation.

THE HISTORICAL LESSON: TRUST IS BUILT WITH LIGHT, NOT WITH SECRECY

Society is not afraid of science.It is afraid of secrecy.Even the cleanest scientific project loses legitimacy if the public cannot understand it and verify it.

PERSONAL TRAGEDY AS A MIRROR OF THE SYSTEM – THE CASE OF GJORGI

There are moments when public issues become personal wounds.The case of Gjorgi is not merely a family tragedy.It is a symbol of a question asked by thousands of parents: does medicine always choose the fight for life as its first option?When doctors insist on procedures that families experience as mechanical and devoid of empathy, trust collapses.And when trust disappears, the healthcare system ceases to be a sanctuary of life.Gjorgi becomes a reminder that behind every medical case stands a human destiny, and behind every decision, a moral weight that cannot be measured by protocols.

THIS IS NOT A CASE FOR A WORKING GROUP — THIS IS A CASE FOR THE PROSECUTION

This is not a case for a working group or a commission.This is a case for an institution created by law.That institution is the prosecution.Everyone speaks of corruption in the judiciary, of trust levels at two percent.But does the disclosure of this case not lead to identical processes in healthcare?Why should the export of brains to the United States not be examined under the same legal and moral lens as the case of Judge Gjoko Ristov?There is no difference.Who can categorically deny that materialized interests, in the form of commissions or benefits, did not exist here as well, built or already consumed?Those involved in this case must explain under which legal framework this material was transferred.
The benefit for science is a story for children if the law has not previously prescribed the procedure for offering human material to science.Family consent, in the absence of law, cannot legalize permission for the extraction of biological material.
The prosecution must investigate.This requires the opening of a case within the Public Prosecutor’s Office — not the formation of side working groups.

THE STATE BEFORE A HISTORICAL TEST

The working group tasked with examining this issue is not merely investigating a medical project.It is investigating trust.It is investigating whether Macedonia will prove that the dignity of its citizens — living or dead — is inviolable.

WHAT MUST BE PUBLICLY ANSWERED

How many samples were sent?Which institutions were involved?What did the consent forms contain?Where are the samples today?Who controls their research use?Without these answers — suspicion will remain.

MACEDONIA BETWEEN SCIENCE AND DIGNITY

Macedonia has the right to be part of global science.But it has an even greater obligation to protect the dignity of its people.Science without morality creates knowledge.Knowledge without morality creates fear.

FINAL THOUGHT: CIVILIZATION IS DEFENDED IN GRAVEYARDS

A society that protects its dead protects its future.If we allow the silence of the deceased to become a currency of interests, we will lose the silence of our own conscience as well.

Please follow and like us: