Opinion by Slobodan TOMIĆ – Carnival or Rule of Law? The Test of Macedonian Institutions

Македонија

By Slobodan TOMIĆ

Slobodan TOMIĆ

“When justice is selective, the state quietly falls.”

inspired by Montesquieu

The scene the entire country witnessed

At the Blace border crossing, Artan Grubi appeared with a smile.It was not an ordinary smile.It was a symbol.Fourteen months of absence.International pressure.Public suspicion.And a return without any visible weight on his face.In politics, symbols sometimes speak louder than press conferences.The question was not just where he would sleep that night.The question was: what does this say about the system?

The black list: a signal that cannot be ignored

When the United States Department of State places a politician on a sanctions list, it is not a court verdict.But it is a serious diplomatic signal.In serious states, such a signal triggers institutional rigor and a demonstration of impartiality.In states with fragile trust, it triggers silence, relativization, and procedural convenience.The public did not react to a legal technicality.The public reacted to the contrast:an international black list, a soft domestic bed.

Responsibility is not one-sided

The current government has the right to insist on reforms in the judiciary.But reforms are not implemented through statements—they are implemented through results.At the same time, the public has the right to ask questions of the previous government, especially for the period when coalition politics shaped the system:why was there no institutional energy then?why were there no visible processes for cases that today stir public concern?If there were indications back then, why did institutions remain silent?If there were none, why is there suspicion today?Silence can weigh heavier than an accusation.

Perception of wealth and the question of trust

For years, questions have circulated in the public space about massive capital expansions, luxury properties, expensive vehicles, and ambitious urban projects.Is everything legal?That is for the courts to say.But when society witnesses dramatic transformations of wealth without clear institutional oversight, suspicion arises—and if unresolved, suspicion becomes erosion of trust.

A captured state or an institutional turning point?

The term “captured state” is used for a system in which institutions formally exist but are essentially paralyzed by political compromises.If the prosecution and judiciary do not demonstrate clear, transparent, and equal application of the law, regardless of party, ethnicity, or previous coalitions, the perception becomes a judgment in the eyes of the public.It is not only a person who is judged.The system is judged.

Carnival or state?

This is not an attack on an individual.This is not a defense of the government.This is a question:will the country be a state where institutions are stronger than politics, or will it remain a space where accountability comes selectively and late?History will not remember the smile.It will remember the outcome.And that is why the dilemma “Carnival or Rule of Law?” is not an insult.It is a test.A test of maturity.A test of institutions.A test of the future.

Please follow and like us: