Opinion by Slobodan Tomić – The Constitution Is Not a Chair — It Is a Sacred Trust

Македонија

“STATES DO NOT FALL WHEN THE ENEMY IS STRONG — THEY FALL WHEN JUSTICE BECOMES A PARTY REWARD.”

Charles de Montesquieu

By Slobodan Tomić

Slobodan Tomić

There comes a moment in the history of every nation when its people begin to ask a single, decisive question:Are institutions guardians of justice — or merely reward posts for political services?Today, North Macedonia stands precisely at that moment.The election of a new constitutional judge has opened a deep, turbulent, yet unavoidable debate:Is this finally the path toward professionalization and reform — or are we once again witnessing justice being used as currency in political bargaining?The truth, however, is complex.And it must be spoken clearly.

KEY DIFFERENCE: REWARD OR RESPONSIBILITY

Being an adviser to a prime minister is not a sin.Being an expert is not a fault.Coming from academia is an honor.That has never been the problem.The real problem in Macedonia has always been when positions are distributed as political rewards instead of state responsibilities.This is why public reaction is not primarily directed against Professor Goce Naumovski.On the contrary, many analysts emphasize that his academic profile, long scholarly career, and non-partisan background are precisely what the Constitutional Court has lacked for years.For that reason, his appointment carries the potential to symbolize a new beginning.WHY THE

PUBLIC IS UNCERTAIN — AND WHY THAT IS UNDERSTANDABLE

Macedonians are not skeptical without reason.They remember.They remember years in which the Constitutional Court was often perceived not as an independent legal body, but as an institution serving political interests.The strongest symbol of that distrust remains Constitutional Court judge Dobrilа Kacarska.For many citizens, her career exemplifies what people call:“you make me a commander, I’ll make you a duke.”Her role in the trials related to the events of April 27, the extremely harsh sentences totaling more than two centuries in prison, and later support for an 80% salary increase for public officials left a deep shadow over trust in constitutional justice.That is why the question people ask today is painful — but legitimate:Can such examples truly serve as guardians of the Constitution?

THE DIVIDE BETWEEN THE OLD AND THE NEW GOVERNANCE MODEL

This is the central political line dividing Macedonia today.Critics argue that during the period of Zoran Zaev and Ali Ahmeti, positions were often distributed as political rewards while institutions steadily lost authority.It was a system in which:justice was treated as a tooljudges were seen as political alliesinstitutions functioned as party strongholdsAnd it was precisely this practice that created the deepest crisis of trust in the Macedonian judiciary.

IS A TURNING POINT NOW HAPPENING?

The current government led by Hristijan Mickoski is attempting to send a different message:That expertise is not politicization.That academia is not dependency.And that an advisory role does not equal political obedience.This is why part of the public support for Naumovski’s appointment rests on a simple logic:If Macedonia wants genuine constitutional judges, they must come from knowledge — not party headquarters.

THE REAL DISEASE: AN UNREFORMED JUDICIARY

Yet the core problem is not an individual.It is systemic.For decades, the Constitutional Court has remained one of the least reformed institutions in the country:no clear operational lawno transparent selection criteriano accountability mechanismsThat is why every new appointment automatically turns into a political crisis.

POLITICS, ETHNICIZATION, AND THE RISK TO JUSTICE

Proposals to introduce ethnic quotas into the Constitutional Court have opened a new danger.If the Court becomes a political or ethnic body, it ceases to be a court at all.It becomes an arbitration arena for interests —a direct path toward constitutional chaos.

THE PEOPLE DO NOT DEMAND MIRACLES — THEY DEMAND JUSTICE

The Macedonian people do not expect perfect judges.They ask for only one thing:no more reward chairsno more party-driven verdictsno more political justice

MACEDONIA FACES A HISTORIC TEST

This moment is not merely about selecting one judge.It is a test of whether Macedonia will finally move:from a party-captured stateto a rule-of-law state.From a system of rewardsto a system of responsibility.

FINAL MESSAGE — AND WARNING

If the Constitutional Court becomes truly independent, Macedonia can become a stable democracy.If it remains partisan, it will become just another country where citizens have no trust in justice.That is why today’s choice is not an ending.It is a beginning.The beginning of the hardest — and most important — struggle:the struggle for the Constitution to stop being paper, and become a living guarantee of justice.

Please follow and like us: