Opinion by Slobodan TOMIĆ – Pacta Sunt Servanda or Europe in Two Speeds

Македонија

By: Slobodan TOMIĆ

Slobodan TOMIĆ

Macedonia: A Test Case for the Crisis of European Methodology

“Politics without principles is merely management of the moment.”(inspired by Raymond Aron)

Raymond Aron

1. Macedonia at the Crossroads of History

Macedonia is not merely a geographic point on the Balkans.It is a historic symbol of continuity of identity and the struggle for legal and institutional frameworks.From World War I, through the communist era, to independence and NATO membership, Macedonia has always tested the principles of international law and the balance of powers.Today, the real test is not whether the state reaches the European threshold, but whether Europe is prepared to honor treaties, uphold the principle of pacta sunt servanda, and treat all states equally.

2. “Pacta sunt servanda”: Mickoski’s Line

Hristijan Mickoski has drawn a clear red line: if Macedonia has fulfilled all its obligations, the EU must guarantee finality.The Prespa Agreement, a historic compromise, was honored with signatures.The bilateral framework with Bulgaria was formally implemented.The French proposal was accepted without additional constitutional safeguards.Mickoski’s stance is uncompromising: without symmetrical guarantees, European integration becomes an instrument of political selection rather than justice.

3. Siljanovska and Constitutional Autonomy

President Gordana Siljanovska-Davkova emphasizes constitutional integrity:The constitution must not be subject to external improvisations.Dynamic agreements cannot become permanent institutional change without clear legal frameworks.Historical parallels are evident: Spain 1986, Greece 1981, Eastern enlargement 2004 — all steps accompanied by concrete institutional guarantees.Macedonia today stands as a state without such protection.

4. Filipce, Zaev’s Shadow, and Transferred Responsibility

The strategic maneuver of Zoran Zaev created a shadow governance model where former power structures continue to operate behind the scenes.Venko Filipce becomes the public face merely transmitting messages.The result: concessions are made without national consensus, while responsibility is diffused.This generates the risk of institutional paralysis and the absence of a coherent national vision.

5.  Knaus and the Bridges of Trust

Gerald Knaus proposes constitutional amendments with conditional implementation.The goal: to reduce asymmetry between fulfilled obligations and guarantee mechanisms.Yet, the very need for such a model highlights a fundamental weakness in European methodology: how can an organization that claims to uphold legal order implement policy dependent on mere “goodwill”?

6.  EU in Two Speeds and Membership Without Voting Rights

Differentiated integration increasingly risks becoming a reality:Gradual inclusion in the single market;Partial participation in institutions;Limited voting rights.While formally no “membership without voting rights” exists, the dual-speed potential exposes the risk: Macedonia could become a second-tier member.For a small state, this is a question of sovereign equality.For Macedonia, it is a question of identity, dignity, and the right to be treated as equal in Europe.

7. Geopolitical Context

Amid the war in Ukraine, the EU positions itself as a geopolitical actor.Ukraine and Moldova received accelerated candidate status.Macedonia, despite NATO membership, remains stagnant.Paradoxically, the most loyal state faces the most unpredictable conditions — a signal that principle is being subordinated to political convenience.

8. Two Speeds in Domestic Politics

The Macedonian domestic political scene is divided into two speeds:Politics with vision: Mickoski and Siljanovska champion principles, finality, and legal certainty. They defend Macedonia’s sovereignty and the integrity of European commitments.Transit politics: The ruling bloc (SDSM and partners) reacts to external signals, transferring responsibility without securing concrete guarantees.This internal split magnifies the risk of “membership without voting rights,” both domestically and within Europe.

9.  Strategic Choice and Historical Lesson

Macedonia must decide:To abandon the principle of pacta sunt servanda and rely on the goodwill of others.To insist on finality and institutional guarantees.To delay any agreements until an internal national consensus is built.The historical lesson is clear: states that lose trust in international rules often forfeit their autonomy and sovereignty.

10.  Finale: Macedonia as Europe’s Mirror

Hannah Arendt warned:“Authority vanishes when people cease to believe that rules apply equally to all.”Macedonia does not seek privilege.It demands predictability.If treaties are to hold, they must have finality.If finality does not exist, enlargement becomes a process without horizon.The smallest states in Europe lose trust fastest when rules are selective.Today, Macedonia reflects the crisis of European methodology, not only Balkan politics — a stark reminder that principle, not expediency, must guide Europe’s future.

Please follow and like us: