Written by: Slobodan TOMIĆ

“In order to prevent the abuse of power, it is necessary that, by the arrangement of things, power should check power.”
Charles-Louis de Montesquieu
A CLASH BETWEEN TWO PILLARS OF THE STATE
When the President of the Assembly of the Republic of Macedonia, Afrim Gashi, and the President of the Constitutional Court of the Republic of Macedonia, Darko Kostadinovski, enter into a public confrontation, it is not a matter of personal intolerance.It is an institutional clash.On one side stands the legislative chamber — the temple of laws.On the other stands the Constitutional Court — the guardian of the Constitution.This clash has opened a fundamental dilemma:is this a case of failing to respect constitutional deadlines, or a matter of shifting responsibility between institutions?In every democratic state, the relationship between legislative power and constitutional judicial oversight is a delicate balance.One institution enacts rules; the other verifies whether those rules are in accordance with the supreme legal act of the state.When that balance is disturbed, the public naturally begins to ask:is this about institutional discipline or a political confrontation?
“A CONSTITUTIONALLY UNDICIPLINED BODY” – A SERIOUS DIAGNOSIS
When the head of the Constitutional Court qualifies the Parliament as a “constitutionally undisciplined body,” it is not an ordinary political statement.It is a serious institutional diagnosis.According to Kostadinovski, the deadlines for harmonizing the Criminal Code and the Law on Electronic Communications were breached.As he points out, the Court had left several opportunities for legislative reaction.However, if the legislative body fails to react in time, the constitutional judiciary may tighten its practice.This means that in the future, interpretative decisions with delayed effect could be avoided.In other words:fewer institutional shock absorbers, more direct legal consequences.But the question that arises is whether institutional reality can truly be reduced to such a simple formula.
THE SPEAKER’S RESPONSE: A COMPLEX PROCEDURE, SHARED RESPONSIBILITY
On the other side, the Speaker of Parliament emphasizes that the legislative process is far more complex than it appears at first glance.In practice, the majority of extensive legislative solutions come as proposals from the Government and the relevant ministries.Without a submitted draft law, Parliament cannot open a formal legislative procedure.Although Members of Parliament and the Assembly have the right to initiate legislation independently, political and administrative practice shows that most systemic reforms originate from the executive branch.This is where the key question arises:is responsibility for the delay borne solely by the legislative branch, or is it an institutional responsibility shared by multiple actors?If the delay stems from the executive branch, then institutional responsibility is broader.But if constitutional deadlines are an absolute obligation regardless of procedure, then institutional discipline must be equally strict for all.
THE DANGER OF ETHNICIZING INSTITUTIONAL ISSUES
Additional weight to the dispute was given by the topic “Safe City,” where some political actors attempted to transform a legal and institutional issue into an ethnic debate.A clear line must be drawn here.When legal dilemmas are turned into ethnic competitions, the state loses.It is not a problem that political parties hold different views.That is the essence of democracy.The problem arises when an institutional dispute turns into an identity confrontation.In such situations, law ceases to be a legal category and becomes a political instrument, whereas a statesmanlike approach demands the opposite:that the law be interpreted legally, not ethnically.
THE CRIMINAL CODE AS A MIRROR OF THE SYSTEM
The Criminal Code is not a technical document.It is the foundation of legal certainty and the functioning of the rule of law.When such a law becomes the subject of an institutional dispute, it inevitably sends a signal to the public that something within the system is not functioning as it should.On one side stands the constitutional deadline.On the other stands the complexity of legislative preparation.But for citizens, that institutional complexity is not the most important issue.Citizens see a simple question:are the institutions working in coordination or not?In law, delay creates legal uncertainty.In politics, legal uncertainty creates distrust.
THE ELECTORAL CODE – A TEST OF MATURITY
The preparation of a new electoral model with open lists may become a true test of the system’s institutional maturity.If political actors manage to reach consensus on such an important issue, it will signal that institutional dialogue functions.But if conflicts continue, then the dispute between institutions may become a symptom of deeper institutional weakness.
THE STATE IS NOT A YARD; IT IS A SHARED HOUSE
In political rhetoric, the phrase “everyone should mind their own yard” is often used.But the state is not a collection of isolated yards.It is a shared house.If one pillar shakes, the other cannot stand with folded arms.If one institution points to a problem, the other must respond with argument, not with qualifications.True institutional balance is not built through public confrontations, but through institutional dialogue.
SUMMARY: WHO PROTECTS TRUST?
This clash is not personal.It is a test of the institutional system’s maturity.The Assembly must demonstrate discipline.The Constitutional Court must demonstrate restraint.Political parties must demonstrate statesmanlike wisdom.Because when institutions begin to accuse one another, citizens begin to doubt — and when trust falls, it is not one government that falls.Stability falls.And therefore, more than ever, institutional sobriety is required.Not for the victory of one side.But for the victory of the state.

