Opinion by Slobodan Tomić – “When the State Does Not Trust Its Own Citizens: A Constitutional Complaint as a Test of Macedonia’s Institutional Maturity”

Македонија Свет

By Slobodan Tomić

Slobodan Tomić

“A state that does not trust its citizens does not trust its own Constitution, and therefore exports justice beyond its borders.”

“Injustice anywhere is a threat to justice everywhere.” 

Martin Luther King Jr.

Not a Question of Whether, but When, and With What Political Courage

In modern constitutional democracies, the constitutional complaint represents the ultimate safeguard of fundamental rights. It is neither symbolic nor rhetorical. It is a legal instrument, an institutional corrective that allows individuals, after exhausting ordinary legal remedies, to appeal directly to the constitutional court.In Macedonia, such a mechanism does not exist.There is a Constitution.There is a Constitutional Court.But there is no individual constitutional complaint as a direct procedural right of the citizen.This is not a minor technical omission. It is an institutional gap that leaves the system structurally incomplete. A state that does not allow individuals to directly seek constitutional protection sends a troubling signal: ultimate oversight of public power does not fully rest in the hands of its citizens.

An Incomplete System: Three Decades Without a Systemic Safeguard

For more than three decades, Macedonia has functioned without a constitutional complaint mechanism. Longevity, however, should not be confused with stability. In this case, it reflects postponement.The President of the Constitutional Court, Darko Kostadinovski, has made it clear that introducing such a mechanism would require constitutional amendments, as well as a dedicated implementing law. This places the issue squarely in the political arena.In Macedonia, constitutional amendments are rarely treated as narrow legal adjustments. They are politically sensitive events, often intertwined with broader national debates. Yet the protection of fundamental rights should not become collateral damage in larger political calculations.

When Justice Is Sought Abroad, the Domestic System Has Failed

The significant number of cases brought against Macedonia before the European Court of Human Rights in Strasbourg is not incidental. It is symptomatic.When citizens must step outside their own legal order to secure protection of fundamental rights, it indicates that domestic remedies were either insufficient or ineffective. Each case in Strasbourg functions as a quiet indictment of institutional shortcomings at home.A constitutional complaint would not eliminate every systemic weakness. But it could serve as an internal corrective — a filter capable of addressing rights violations within the national legal order before they escalate into international litigation.

The Political Dimension: Support in Principle, Caution in Timing

Prime Minister Hristijan Mickoski has expressed principled support for the introduction of a constitutional complaint, while also acknowledging the political sensitivity of reopening the Constitution at this stage.This position reflects a broader reality: constitutional reform in Macedonia is rarely perceived as technical. It is viewed as a turning point, often with implications beyond the immediate legal question.Yet long-term institutional stability cannot be built without gradually strengthening mechanisms of constitutional oversight. Legal certainty cannot remain indefinitely subordinate to political timing.

The European Perspective: Functionality Over Formalism

European democratic standards do not prescribe a single institutional model. What they require is effectiveness.The essential question is straightforward: does the Constitutional Court possess a realistic capacity to protect fundamental rights when they are violated?A constitutional complaint is not merely a gesture of European alignment. It is a practical instrument for reinforcing the rule of law domestically and rebuilding public trust in state institutions.

Fear of Judicial Overreach: Argument or Pretext?

Critics argue that introducing a constitutional complaint could lead to excessive concentration of power in the Constitutional Court. This concern deserves serious legal consideration.However, the absence of a mechanism does not create balance. It creates a vacuum.With clearly defined admissibility criteria, procedural safeguards, and transparent jurisprudence, a constitutional complaint can enhance legal certainty rather than undermine institutional equilibrium.

Political Will as the Final Test

Constitutional amendments require a two-thirds majority — a demanding threshold that implies compromise and shared responsibility.If there is broad acknowledgment that a constitutional complaint is necessary, continued postponement becomes a conscious political choice. And every such choice carries consequences: diminished trust in institutions, prolonged legal uncertainty, and a slower path toward substantive rule of law.

A Defining Choice for Institutional Maturity

Macedonia does not face a conceptual dilemma. Comparative models exist. European practice is well developed. The expert community has debated this issue for years.What remains is political decision.Will the country build a system in which justice can be secured at home?Or will it continue to rely on external adjudication as a corrective mechanism?A constitutional complaint is not a symbolic reform.It is a test of institutional maturity.A test of confidence in the domestic legal order.A test of political courage.And that is why the question is no longer whether.The question is when?

Please follow and like us: