By Slobodan Tomić

“Those who understand their history can shape their future.”
Arnold Toynbee
The history of the Balkans has never been only a story of the past.
It has often been a tool of politics, diplomacy and influence.
In a region where empires have risen and fallen, borders have shifted, and communities have lived under different state structures, questions of origin, identity and belonging have always carried a deeper meaning than in many other parts of Europe.
That is why every new debate over citizenship based on ancestry cannot be viewed merely as an administrative procedure.
It is also a political, historical and geopolitical question.
The message from the Greek Embassy in Skopje:
“Greece needs you. Strengthen your connection with your homeland.”
has attracted public attention in Macedonia and opened a broader debate.
Greece has launched an information campaign targeting people who believe they have Greek ancestry and who may meet the legal requirements for acquiring Greek citizenship based on descent.
From a legal perspective, every state has the sovereign right to define the conditions for citizenship.
Countries around the world follow different models: some are based on birthplace, others on family origin, and others on historical and cultural ties with their diaspora.
But the Balkans have a unique characteristic.
Here, citizenship has rarely been only a document.
It is often also a message.
A message about belonging, historical connection and political identity.
That is why every process linked to ancestry and citizenship in Macedonia naturally receives heightened attention.
THE BULGARIAN MODEL AND MACEDONIA’S EXPERIENCE
In recent years, Macedonia witnessed a process in which Bulgarian citizenship became one of the most significant social and political issues.
Thousands of citizens applied for Bulgarian passports.
The reasons were different.
For many, it was primarily an economic opportunity: easier access to the European labour market, employment possibilities, education and freedom of movement within the European Union.
However, alongside the administrative process, a deeper question emerged:
Does citizenship remain only an individual legal right, or can it become an instrument influencing historical narratives and identity?
This is at the heart of the Balkan dilemma.
No one can deny an individual’s right to seek citizenship if legal conditions are fulfilled.
But when citizenship becomes connected with sensitive historical questions, an individual administrative decision can acquire a wider social and political dimension.
Therefore, as Greece now reaches out to people in Macedonia who believe they have Greek ancestry, a new question emerges:
Is the Balkans entering a new phase of “passport diplomacy”, where influence is built not only through territory and politics, but also through citizenship and historical connections?
THE GREEK APPROACH: LEGAL PROCESS OR A NEW GEOPOLITICAL MESSAGE?
The policies of Bulgaria and Greece should not automatically be placed in the same category.
Each country has its own legislation, history and approach toward its diaspora.
Greece has maintained policies for decades aimed at people of Greek origin around the world.
However, when such policies are directed toward a neighbouring country with a complex historical background, the questions become more sensitive.
The key question is not whether there is a legal possibility.
The key question is:
How does a state use that possibility?
Is the process transparent, individual and strictly based on law?
Or does it become part of a broader strategy for expanding cultural and political influence?
The answer will depend on how the process is implemented.
FROM TSIPRAS–ZAEV TO A NEW BALKAN REALITY
Political agreements between states can regulate relations between governments, but they are far more difficult to erase historical questions.
The period following the Prespa Agreement between Alexis Tsipras and Zoran Zaev is a clear example.
At the time, the agreement was presented as the closing of a long and difficult chapter and the beginning of a new era of cooperation between Greece and Macedonia.
It created a new reality in international relations and raised expectations that historical disputes would gradually be replaced by European cooperation, economic projects and mutual trust.
But years later, one lesson has become clear:
Political agreements can reshape institutional relations between governments, but they cannot automatically change deep historical perceptions among societies.
History continues to live through:
education,
culture,
archives,
language,
historical interpretations,
questions of belonging.
The Balkans continue to demonstrate an old lesson:
Borders can be changed through agreements, but historical narratives are far more difficult to change.
PASSPORT DIPLOMACY IN THE BALKANS: WHEN HISTORY BECOMES INFLUENCE
In today’s world, influence between states is no longer built only through economic power, military strength or territory.
It is also built through:
culture, education, language, diaspora and historical connections.
Citizenship in such a context can simply be a legal instrument.
But it can also become part of a broader strategy of maintaining connections with people beyond national borders.
That is why the Balkans are facing a new type of competition.
Not a competition for new borders.
But a competition for influence.
From Bulgarian passports to Greek appeals directed at people with possible ancestry, the same fundamental question emerges:
Who shapes the story of the past, and who influences the future?
Of course, every individual has the right to make personal decisions.
No one can deny citizens the right to seek economic opportunities, a better future or a legal connection with another country.
But states must understand that in regions with unresolved historical questions, every political step carries symbolism.
GREECE AND BULGARIA: DIFFERENT POLICIES, ONE SENSITIVE QUESTION
Greece and Bulgaria have different historical positions and different state policies.
Not every process can be placed in the same context.
However, Macedonia’s experience demonstrates one important reality:
Identity questions in the Balkans are rarely only private matters.
They often become part of international politics.
That is why every policy connected with ancestry, history and citizenship must be analysed with reason and responsibility.
Not with fear.
Not with hostility.
But with awareness that smaller states must understand the processes taking place around them.
EUROPE BEFORE THE BALKAN CHALLENGE
The European Union is built on the principles of free movement, individual rights and respect for diversity.
These values must be protected.
But enlargement toward the Western Balkans shows that historical questions still carry enormous political weight.
Europe must understand that this region is not only a collection of administrative procedures and technical reforms.
It is also a region of historical memory, trust issues and questions of equality.
Therefore, European integration cannot be only about fulfilling conditions.
It must also be a process of building confidence.
And confidence cannot exist without equal rules for everyone.
EUROPEAN VALUES AND BALKAN PARADOXES: WHO APPLIES THE SAME STANDARDS?
The European Union is right to insist on the rule of law, independent institutions, the fight against corruption and functional democratic systems.
These are not merely membership requirements.
They are the foundations of a modern state.
But this creates a broader question frequently raised in Macedonia:
Are European principles applied equally to all countries and all policies in the Balkans?
The European message must be clear:
If individual rights are fundamental, they must apply to everyone.
But if history and identity remain sensitive issues, Europe must also understand that every political move in this region can have wider consequences.
The citizenship debate is not only about the number of passports issued.
It is about how states build relationships with people beyond their borders.
And here Europe has a responsibility:
To protect individual rights, but also to prevent historical disputes from becoming instruments of political influence.
(Продолжува…)
ROKAS: EUROPE OPENS THE DOOR — BUT DOES IT SEE ALL THE PROCESSES?
The message by European Ambassador Michalis Rokas that the European Union wants to see Macedonia as a full member is significant.
It confirms that the European perspective remains alive.
But precisely this message raises a fundamental question:
If Europe demands that Macedonia meet strict criteria, does it apply the same principles when examining the policies of neighbouring countries?
Macedonia has clear obligations.
It must continue implementing reforms.
It must strengthen the rule of law.
It must build independent institutions.
It must ensure an effective fight against corruption.
But European policy must also be a policy of equal standards.
Citizens expect Europe not only to evaluate reforms, but also to defend principles.
The credibility of the European project depends on consistency.
Because Europe cannot ask candidate countries to believe in common values while allowing different interpretations of those values depending on political circumstances.
FILIPCHE AND THE EUROPEAN DEBATE: WHEN EUROPEAN ISSUES BECOME DOMESTIC POLITICAL BATTLES
The debate at the National Council for European Integration once again revealed the deep political divisions surrounding Macedonia’s European path.
Opposition leader Venko Filipche strongly criticised the government, accusing it of political influence over the judiciary and of slowing down European processes.
In a democratic society, the role of the opposition is essential.
It has the right and responsibility to question the government and demand accountability.
But European integration cannot become only a weapon in domestic political battles.
European reforms require responsibility from everyone:
from the government,
from the opposition,
and from state institutions.
Because weaknesses in the rule of law are not created overnight.
They are the result of long-term institutional challenges.
The greatest danger is when the European agenda becomes a tool of daily political confrontation instead of a national strategic goal.
MACEDONIA MUST NOT SEEK ITS FUTURE THROUGH OTHER COUNTRIES’ PASSPORTS
The strongest response of any state is not fear of the processes happening around it.
The strongest response is its own success.
When citizens have:
economic opportunities,
legal security,
trust in institutions,
quality education,
the possibility of a dignified life,
then a second citizenship is no longer a necessity.
It becomes only an additional option.
A country does not protect its identity through isolation.
It protects it through success.
Through knowledge.
Through culture.
Through strong institutions.
Through confidence.
The greatest task for Macedonia is to build a state where young people want to create their future at home.
Because the strongest defence of identity is not a document.
It is a successful country.
HISTORY CAN BE A BRIDGE — BUT IT CAN ALSO BECOME A WEAPON
The Balkans carry an old lesson that continues to repeat itself:
History itself does not create conflicts. The way politics uses history can create divisions.
The past can be a bridge between peoples.
It can become a foundation for respect, cooperation and understanding.
But it can also become a tool of political influence when it is used to create new divisions, pressures or competitions over identity.
Therefore, the question of citizenship must be viewed in a broader context.
The issue is not whether an individual has the right to seek citizenship if legal requirements are fulfilled.
That is an individual right.
The issue is how states use their policies and what message they send in a region where historical questions remain part of political reality.
Because in international relations, influence is not created only through territory.
It is also created through ideas, culture, language, education and connections with people.
THE NEW BATTLE IN THE BALKANS IS NOT ABOUT BORDERS — IT IS ABOUT INFLUENCE
Today, the Balkans are not facing the danger of a new redrawing of borders.
But they are facing a different type of competition.
A competition for influence.
For historical memory.
For cultural connections.
For the ability to present one’s own narrative to future generations.
That is why questions of ancestry, diaspora and citizenship have become part of a wider geopolitical picture.
Not because every individual decision carries a political intention.
But because states understand that connections with people beyond their borders can become an important resource.
In the 21st century, influence is often built quietly.
Through education.
Through culture.
Through language.
Through historical interpretation.
Through networks of people.
The new geopolitical competition is not always visible.
Sometimes it does not happen through conflicts.
It happens through narratives.
EUROPE CANNOT BE ONLY A JUDGE — IT MUST ALSO BE A GUARANTOR OF EQUAL RULES
Macedonia has a clear responsibility:
to implement reforms,
to strengthen the rule of law,
to build independent institutions.
These are obligations that every candidate country must respect.
But the European Union also has a responsibility:
to demonstrate that its values are universal.
If Europe speaks about equality, then equality must also be felt in sensitive questions of history, identity and citizenship.
If Europe speaks about overcoming national disputes, then it must be careful when historical issues once again become instruments of political influence.
The European future of the Balkans will not depend only on reform reports and technical benchmarks.
It will depend on trust.
And trust can exist only when citizens believe that the same rules apply to everyone.
MACEDONIA MUST RESPOND WITH THE STRENGTH OF A STATE, NOT WITH FEAR
To every process around it, Macedonia must respond with maturity.
Not with isolation.
Not with fear.
But with construction.
With strong institutions.
With economic development.
With education that creates confident generations.
With culture that understands and respects its own history.
Because the identity of a nation is not protected by administrative measures.
It is protected by the fact that the state is successful, stable and respected.
No passport can replace the strength of a functional country.
No political campaign can erase the history of a people that possesses confidence and self-respect.
CONCLUSION: PASSPORTS DO NOT WRITE HISTORY — PEOPLE WRITE HISTORY THROUGH THEIR ACTIONS
The Greek outreach to people with possible Greek ancestry, as well as Macedonia’s experience with Bulgarian citizenship, opens a wider Balkan question:
How is influence created in the 21st century?
The answer is clear:
Not only through power.
But through politics, culture, economy and trust.
The greatest response of Macedonia is not fear of the policies of others.
The greatest response is to build a country where citizens see their future.
Because a state that gives hope to its people has the strongest defence of its identity.
And Europe will succeed only if it proves that its principles apply equally to everyone.
The future of the Balkans will not be determined only by agreements and passports.
It will be determined by the maturity of states, the wisdom of policies and respect for truth.
Slobodan Tomić

